Problem 01
The search nobody noticed
Cliqz's strategic bet was to never look like a Google competitor. There was no search results page — deliberately. Burda did not want to declare war on Google and did not want to be marketed as its rival, so search lived inside the address bar: you started typing, and the top three results dropped down underneath, live, at roughly 160 ms per keystroke.
On paper this was strictly better. No page load, no round trip, about two seconds saved per answered query. In testing it did move behaviour — people who used the dropdown sent noticeably fewer queries onward to Google.
But watch a real person type a query and you see the flaw immediately: they are looking at the keyboard. There is no Enter key, no page transition, no tab change — none of the signals a browser normally uses to say "something happened." Users typed their query blind, looked up, hit Enter out of twenty years of muscle memory, and landed on Google anyway. We had not built a slow product. We had built a fast one that fired in the one second nobody was watching.
A dedicated search page — the thing that would have made the product legible in a single glance — only shipped in beta in December 2019. The shutdown was announced five months later.
The perception gap
What shipped
- Wetter Berlin — heute 18°C, bewölktwetter.com
- Wetter Berlin 14-Tage-Trendwetter.de
- Berlin — Wetterbericht & Warnungendwd.de
~160 ms
per keystroke
Top 3
plus history & tabs
~2 s
saved per answered query
What users experienced
Eyes down on the keyboard.
No Enter key. No page load. No tab change. Nothing in the interface announced that the answer had already arrived — so people finished typing, pressed Enter, and left for Google out of habit.
The finding: we had not built a slow product. We had built a fast one that fired during the one second the user was not watching.
